Sarah Jessica Parker and John Corbett - 1

Rumors that the second season of HBO’s And Just Like That series could feature an old love affair brought back to life has fans seeing red. Star Sarah Jessica Parker recently hinted that she and John Corbett could be reprising their relationship as on-screen couple Carrie Bradshaw and Aidan Shaw — and people have thoughts .

SJP broke the internet when she shared a series of snapshots from the set.

View this post on Instagram A post shared by SJP (@sarahjessicaparker)

Move over, Kim Kardashian: There’s a new photo everyone is talking about. In this one, Sarah and John can be seen locking lips as their characters, Carrie and Aidan .

“This. Is. Not. A. Drill,” Sarah dramatically captioned the post, which features more snaps of them caught in a cozy embrace.

There was plenty of speculation about what John’s role will be when photos started leaking.

Ohhhh Carrie and Aiden pic.twitter.com/MjoZrzxQWH — (@BrattyWeeRiot) February 12, 2023

Early word on the street was that John had been caught on set (and smoking — something Aidan would never done!) filming for the series’ second season. Given everything that transpired last season, with Big dying unexpectedly, it’s easy to imagine that Aidan was simply there to check on his old friend. But based on SJP’s posts, it looks like there could be some romance for the pair.

Fans didn’t hold back about the potential news.

Aiden back with Carrie is exactly why that reboot is awful. He was way too good for her. She was awful to him, she had her chances! and blew them. He was happily married with a baby. Come on. — ElJay01 (@Jay01El) February 11, 2023

People are not being shy when it comes to their feelings about seeing Carrie and Aidan getting a second (or is it a fourth?) chance at love.

“Aidan need to go to therapy and learn to love himself and put himself first,” one person tweeted . “Carrie and Big deserved each other. Carrie never deserved Aidan, and he deserved better than her.”

There are plenty of reasons why fans don’t think the storyline will work.

“Old Navy’s account (?) commented, ‘Carrie in her Bennifer era!!!’” https://t.co/IgL5FIpQTH — Tim Kiladze (@timkiladze) February 10, 2023

“Carrie getting back with Aidan is not what they think it is, and that’s poor writing and shock value,” an angry viewer tweeted , hinting at the possibility that the kiss could be something like a flashback or dream scene.

Another person questioned the logistics of the relationship, considering the last time we saw Aidan he was happily married and starting a family. “Also, he has kids. Carrie didn’t want kids,” the person tweeted . “How will they explain this?”

But some people were happy about the news.

Carrie finally ending up with Aiden is what women needed. I think the 90s were obsessed with toxic relationships so believed Big had to be the love of her life. Her getting with Aiden sends a positive message to women everywhere — FEYONCÉ (@Oloni) February 10, 2023

“Carrie finally ending up with Aiden is what women needed,” an excited fan wrote . “I think the ’90s were obsessed with toxic relationships so believed Big had to be the love of her life. Her getting with Aiden sends a positive message to women everywhere.”

Love it or hate it, it’s clear this Carrie/Aidan reunion will have people tuning in. We know we’ll be watching to find out exactly what goes down!